10 Common Mistakes Beginners Make in Soap Making (And How to Avoid Them)
10 Common Mistakes Beginners Make in Soap Making (And How to Avoid Them)
Blog Article
There’s nothing quite like holding a bar of soap that you made with your own two hands. It smells like your favorite scent, looks exactly how you imagined, and feels great on your skin. But if you’ve just started your soap-making journey, you’ve probably realized—this craft isn’t as “easy-peasy” as it looks on Instagram.
That’s okay. Mistakes are part of the process. But if you can dodge a few common ones early on, it’ll make the experience a whole lot smoother. Here are 10 beginner mistakes I made (or nearly made) and how you can avoid them.
1. Winging the Measurements
Soap-making is part science, part art—and the science part matters. Eyeballing your ingredients or “guessing” your lye ratio is a fast track to ruined soap. It either won’t set, or worse, it’ll irritate your skin.
Tip: Use a digital scale for everything. Even a small miscalculation can mess with your batch. Trust me—I learned this the hard way.
2. Skipping Safety Gear (Please Don’t)
The first time I worked with lye, I didn’t think goggles or gloves were “that” necessary. Big mistake. Lye is serious stuff—it can burn your skin and eyes if you're not careful.
Tip: Always wear gloves, goggles, and work in a well-ventilated space. Keep vinegar nearby in case of spills.
3. Choosing the Wrong Oils
Every oil acts differently in soap. Some make it creamy, some make it bubbly, and some make it harden faster. I used all the “fancy” oils in my first batch, and the result was a greasy mess.
Tip: Stick to beginner-friendly oils like coconut, olive, or castor oil. Once you're comfortable, then you can experiment.
4. Not Knowing the Difference Between Soap Bases
If you're doing melt-and-pour, not all soap bases are created equal. Some are clear, some are creamy, and some come with added benefits like aloe vera or goat milk.
Tip: Start with a basic soap base that suits your skin type and project goals.
5. Using the Wrong Colors
Using food coloring or unsafe dyes can turn your soap into a funky, blotchy mess. Worse—it can stain your skin or clothes.
Tip: Always go for skin-safe soap colors designed specifically for soap making. They blend better and won’t bleed or fade.
6. Fragrance Overload
More scent isn’t always better. In fact, over-fragrancing can make the soap soft, irritate skin, or even cause the batch to seize.
Tip: Stick to proper usage rates and use high-quality spa oils or essential oils for a gentle, lasting scent.
7. Unmolding Too Early
I get it—you want to see your final product! But pulling the soap out of the mold before it’s ready usually means dents, cracks, or sticking.
Tip: Be patient. Most soaps need at least 24–48 hours to set properly. And yes, it’s worth the wait.
8. Going Overboard With Add-ins
I once added dried flowers, coffee grounds, oatmeal, and honey—all in the same batch. It looked like a compost brick.
Tip: Keep it simple. One or two natural add-ins like clay powder or dried flowers are more than enough to add texture and benefits.
9. Skipping a Soap Cutter
A knife can cut your soap—but it’s rarely straight or smooth. My early soaps looked like a toddler sliced them with a spoon.
Tip: Use a proper soap cutter for clean, even bars. It makes a big difference in presentation.
10. Expecting Perfection from Day One
Soap-making is a skill. Your first few batches might not look or feel perfect—and that’s completely okay.
Tip: Keep a journal. Note what worked, what didn’t, and what you want to try next time. Over time, you’ll not only get better, but you’ll develop your own style too.
Final Thoughts
Mistakes in soap making are like little lessons in disguise. The key is not to get discouraged. Every time you melt, pour, mix, or mold—you’re learning. So go easy on yourself, stay curious, and don’t forget to have fun with it.
Because at the end of the day, handmade soap is more than just skincare. It’s self-care, creativity, and a craft you’ll love more with every bar.
Report this page